The question of whether human cloning should be permitted

Should Cloning Be Permitted Essay

Therefore, policies that would prohibit the implantation of clonal human embryos would often be unenforceable and would fail to deter human reproductive cloning. They believe this proposal offers the best available way to a wise and prudent policy Both recommendations, and supporting arguments, are presented at length in Chapter 8 of the report.

Debate: Ban on human reproductive cloning

It has been said that a human clone would not find the meaning of humanity and become unique. In my opinion, I state that, no matter who pays for it or for what reason is done, should be made a criminal offense in the U. In the 19th century, vulnerable human beings were bought and sold in the town square as slaves and bred as though they were animals.

The similar personalities of progenitor and offspring often amplified the problems of parenthood, rather than diminishing them. Many countries have passed laws regarding one or both uses of human cloning.

The recent succession of advances in non-embryonic stem cell research indicate that we have not yet reached that point of determination.

Disagreements over the ethical and policy positions regarding human cloning do not seem to fall along lines of science and religion.

A majority of the Council ten members recommended a ban on cloning-to-produce-children combined with a four-year moratorium on cloning-for-biomedical-research, and also called for a federal review of current and projected practices of human embryo research, pre-implantation genetic diagnosis, genetic modification of human embryos and gametes, and related matters.

What are the arguments for and against cloning for biomedical research? A policy advocating the use of clonal human embryos in destructive research would violate the rights of human beings not to be experimented upon.

Disagreements over the ethical and policy positions regarding human cloning do not seem to fall along lines of science and religion. It is not far-fetched to imagine an unscrupulous multi-millionaire cloning himself in this manner -- in case he should ever need a kidney, heart, eye, bone marrow, etc.

In my point of view, I believe that they are going to be more poorer than they are. Support for this premise is as follows: Failure to set standards which are ethical will cause this country--and perhaps others--to reap once again the tragic consequences of unethical scientific and medical research.

A cloned human embryo does not result from the random union of sperm and egg, but from a process called somatic cell nuclear transfer, in which the nucleus containing DNA from a cell of one individual is put into an egg whose nucleus has been removed.

A minority of the Council seven members recommended a ban on cloning-to-produce-children, with federal regulation of the use of cloned embryos for biomedical research.

Human cloning produces individuals artificially. To ignore this responsibility would be to engage in morally unacceptable age discrimination, resulting in the disregard for and destruction of human life based solely on its developmental stage. The moral outcry against this aspect of the proposal, however, was almost universal.

See Chapters 4 and 6 of the report. Why might anyone want to clone a child? Technology seems to take away many of the morals that we have worked so hard to install in society. The Council of Europe has already passed a ban on cloning; to date, 24 countries including Germany, France, Italy and Japan have already enacted national bans on cloning, while 16 have banned creation of embryos for research purposes.

Though both seek a ban on what is being called "reproductive" cloning--in which a clonal human embryo is implanted in a woman with the intent that a cloned human being will be born--they differ dramatically with respect to what is being termed "therapeutic" cloning.

Human embryos are not mere biological tissues or clusters of cells; they are the tiniest of human beings. Can two people share the one soul? It has been said, that each human life is unique, born of a miracle that reaches beyond laboratory science. Using somatic cell nuclear transfer and other cloning technologies, biotech researchers will continue to learn about cell differentiation, re-programming and other areas of cell and molecular biology.

Cloning-for-biomedical-research also raises new questions about the manipulation of some human beings for the benefit of others, the freedom and value of biomedical inquiry, our obligation to heal the sick and its limitsand the respect and protection owed to nascent human life.

In cases like these, authorities would be hard pressed to deny the wishes of those desiring to implant a clonal embryo. One thing that strongly disagrees is what possible consequence can be produced by cloning. Realizing that their prospect for having a genetically related child suddenly appears to be compromised, the man changes his mind and requests that his clone be implanted in his wife instead.Whether or not popular opinion is the best stand for this controversy is addressed by attempting to answer the above questions and to conclude whether or not human reproductive cloning should be effectively banned.

Moreover, the supporters for human cloning argue that human cloning should be allowed, as the research may have to potential to eliminate many of the world’s problems such as animal extinction and can also benefit man kind in many ways.

Still society continues to face the question, should we allow human cloning in the name of science. Unfortunately, many people find this to be a tough question to.

The overwhelming consensus in this country that human reproductive cloning should not be permitted necessitates a ban on both reproductive and "therapeutic" cloning. An overwhelming majority of scientists, lawyers, health care professionals, ethicists and the general public has spoken out strongly against creating a human baby via what is.

about Human Cloning and the Council's Report: "Human Cloning and Human Dignity: An Ethical especially about whether society can or should exercise ethical and prudential control over biomedical technology and the conduct of biomedical research.

Rarely has such a seemingly small innovation raised such large questions. What does U.S. law.

Should Cloning Be Permitted

Human Cloning Should be Condemned On November 25,the news that a firm called Advanced Cell Technology had created human embryos by cloning added new urgency to Congress's and the nation's deliberations on this issue.

Download
The question of whether human cloning should be permitted
Rated 5/5 based on 68 review